​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

LEDVANCE 4/17/2022 Lighting Comparisons

LED vs. Fluorescent Tubes: Which is Right for You?


When it comes to tube lights, there are two main options available in today's market: Fluorescent Tubes and LED Tubes. Both options offer potential benefits. In this blog, we will provide a comprehensive guide comparing LED vs. Fluorescent lights, helping you determine which one best suits your needs. Keep reading to find out more.​



fluorescent vs led 

LED vs Fluorescent Tube Comparison Chart


Discover the key differences between LED and fluorescent tubes in our handy comparison chart!


​
​​

​LED Tube

 ​Fluorescent

Lifespan

​

​Typically have a minimum manufacturer's rating of 50,000 hours, while state-of-the-art specialty products can reach up to 200,000 hours.

​Typically have a longevity rating ranging from 6,000 to 15,000 hours, with the top products in the industry reaching up to 35,000 hours.

Lighting Method

​

Through the movement of electrons in semiconductor materials.​

​By sending electrical discharges through an ionized gas within the tube.
​

Energy Saving

​Highly energy efficient, it uses only 6-8 watts of electricity compared to the 60 watts used by incandescent lights.

​Fluorescent tubes are more energy efficient than incandescent bulbs but less efficient than LED technologies.
​

Maintenance

​The maximum use limit reaches 10 years.

Generally 3-5 years.​
​

Lumens

​Produce roughly 130 lumens per watt.

Produce between 50 and 100 lumens per watt​
​

Application

LED tubes find applications in the automotive, advertising, aviation, and traffic industries. LED lighting is versatile and applicable to nearly all types of fixtures.​

​The applications for fluorescent tubes include gardening, tanning salons, germicidal needs, and bilirubin elimination. It's typically used for stationary lighting needs in an indoor environment.



Why LEDs Outshine Fluorescent Tubes?


LED lights have become a popular alternative to fluorescent lights due to their numerous benefits, such as improved energy efficiency, longer lifespan, and better light quality. Here are the top 6 reasons why LED lights are a superior choice over fluorescent lights.​​​

led office lighting

  • ​Higher Safety Index


    LED lights offer a higher safety index, making them suitable for many places like warehouses, offices, and classrooms. They operate at cooler temperatures, reducing the risk of accidents. Additionally, LED lights do not contain harmful chemicals like mercury, making them a healthier choice. If you prioritize health and safety, LED lights are the optimal option for you.​​


  • ​Energy Saving


    LED lights are significantly more energy efficient than fluorescent lights, consuming up to 40% less energy. Switching to LED lights can save money on energy bills and reduce electricity-related costs. ​​​​

  • ​Long-lasting


    As mentioned on the  LED vs Fluorescent Tube Comparison Chart, LED lights have an impressive lifespan of up to 50,000 hours, significantly reducing maintenance costs. In contrast, fluorescent lights typically last around 6,000 to 15,000 hours, requiring more frequent replacements. This means that LED lights outlast fluorescent lights by 3-8 times, providing substantial longevity benefits.


  • Better for Regular on And Off Switching


    LED lights are ideal for environments that require regular on and off switching, such as warehouses, laboratories, offices, and meeting rooms. Unlike fluorescent lights, which flicker when switched frequently, LED lights are specifically designed for such usage and maintain consistent illumination without flickering or turning off.


  • No Annoying Buzz or Flickering with LED Lights


    Fluorescent lights have a tendency to buzz and flicker, which can be distracting and negatively impact concentration, especially in environments like hospitals and schools. In contrast, LED lights do not buzz or flicker, providing a superior lighting solution without these issues.​​​



led tube application 

​

  • ​Can be Dimmed Easily


    LED lights can be easily dimmed to create the ideal lighting for many tasks. Dimming LED lights reduces glare, minimizes eye strain, and saves energy. Additionally, you can automate the dimming process by using a light sensor, further enhancing energy efficiency. If you are seeking lighting that can be adjusted to suit different tasks, LED lights are the ideal choice.​


Bonus Tip: How to Choose LED Lights?


If you want to use LED tubes at home or in a commercial building, it is crucial to know the different factors that can impact your decision. Here is the information you'll need to know to choose the correct product for each space. And we’ll list some recommended products in LEDVANCE for you.​


  • Shape and Size


    LED bulbs are available in four common types: A-shape, reflectors, decorative, and specialty. A-shape LEDs are commonly used in households. Reflectors, also known as flood or spotlights, are often used for outdoor lighting. Decorative LEDs are designed for sconces, chandeliers, and exposed-bulb fixtures. They come in various sizes, including smaller bulbs for fixtures and larger globes or vintage-style shapes to suit different home decor styles.​


  • Lumens Rating


    Review the bulb's energy rating by examining the wattage. Typically, around 800 lumens is suitable for most indoor environments. For a warmer ambiance, you can opt for around 500 lumens, or go higher if you prefer daylight-like brightness.​​



Recommended Product:​​

  • Color Temperature


    Choose 2,700K for warm tones or 4,000K+ for a cooler, daylight-like effect.
    ​​

Recommended Product:​​

​In Brief​


After exploring our comprehensive guide on fluorescent vs LED lighting, you'll have the knowledge to make the best choice for your project. At LEDVANCE, we offer a wide range of fluorescent and LED products. For more details about our products, please contact us, and we'll respond promptly.​

STAY UP TO DATE WITH LEDVANCE

Sign up to our newsletter to receive LEDVANCE product launches, company news and promotion and contest information straight to your inbox.